Recent headlines have made bold claims about a supposed link between plant-based milk consumption and mental health, prompting many to wonder if their choice of milk could influence their risk of depression. But how much of this is backed by science, and how much is simply sensationalism? Here’s a closer look at the research behind the headlines and what it truly reveals.
The Study Behind the Headlines
A study published in Frontiers in Nutrition explored the relationship between milk consumption and mental health outcomes, such as depression and anxiety, using data from 357,568 UK adults aged 37 to 73. Participants self-reported their dietary habits, including milk preferences, and completed mental health assessments. They were followed for an average of 13.5 years.
Key findings included:
- Semi-skimmed milk was associated with a 12% lower risk of depression and a 10% lower risk of anxiety compared to non-milk drinkers.
- Full-fat milk was linked to a 16% lower risk of anxiety.
- Consumers of plant-based milks, categorised with “other types of milk,” had a 14% higher risk of depression compared to those who drank no milk.
To strengthen their conclusions, researchers applied Mendelian Randomisation (MR) to assess causality for semi-skimmed milk, confirming its protective effects against depression and anxiety. However, MR was not conducted for other milk types, including plant-based options.
What Do These Results Really Mean?
While the findings are intriguing, they should be interpreted with caution. Observational studies like this one can identify associations but cannot prove causation. Several important limitations should be considered:
- Grouping of Plant-Based Milks
The study grouped all plant-based milks (e.g., soy, almond, oat) into a single category. This makes it impossible to determine whether any specific type of plant-based milk is linked to mental health outcomes. The nutritional profiles of these milks can vary significantly. - Lack of Data on Quantity
The amount of milk consumed by participants was not recorded. Variations in serving size could influence the results. - Nutritional Composition of Plant-Based Milks
Many plant-based milks are fortified with calcium and other nutrients. The lack of data on fortification raises questions about their potential impact on mental health. - Residual Confounding
Factors such as overall diet quality, total calorie intake, and socioeconomic status could influence both milk choice and mental health. These variables were not fully accounted for. - Generalisation
The study participants were predominantly middle-aged adults of European descent, which limits the generalisability of the findings to other populations.
Clickbait and Misinterpretation
Media outlets have sensationalised the study’s results, with some suggesting that plant-based milk causes depression or that vegan diets are harmful. However, the study did not assess vegan diets or identify participants as vegan. It simply examined milk consumption habits.
For instance, while the study noted a 14% higher risk of depression for consumers of plant-based milk, this represents a small absolute increase—from 4% to approximately 4.3% risk. This nuance is often overlooked in dramatic headlines.
The Bigger Picture: Diet, Lifestyle, and Mental Health
Mental health is shaped by a complex interplay of genetic, environmental, and lifestyle factors. Diet is just one piece of the puzzle. Evidence suggests that balanced diets, such as the Mediterranean diet—rich in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and fish—can promote mental well-being.
Well-planned plant-based diets can also provide essential nutrients for mental health. Fortified plant-based milks can be excellent sources of calcium, vitamin D, and omega-3 fatty acids, all of which support brain health.
Conclusion
The study linking plant-based milk to a higher risk of depression has sparked significant discussion, but its findings must be interpreted with care. While it raises interesting questions about the relationship between milk consumption and mental health, it does not offer definitive answers. A balanced diet, tailored to individual needs, remains the best approach for overall well-being.
To read the full study
For more infromation and commentaries about the study
